Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clintavo's avatar

YES. The "goal" of a song might be to get to the end of it. But that's certainly not the purpose, as you eloquently point out.

To Bonamassa's point it's not just that mistakes are more human but also that humans can use innate creativity to turn a mistake into a result that is even better than playing it "perfectly" would have been.

Miles Davis famously said, "It’s not the note you play that’s the wrong note – it’s the note you play afterwards that makes it right or wrong.” ― Miles Davis.

The point about mistakes can be pushed even further. What about a deliberate attempt to "ruin" a song?

In the song, "Creep" by Radiohead, the guitarist INTENTIONALLY tried to ruin the song because he didn't like it. Just before the chorus, there are a couple of iconic, harsh guitar "stabs" that guitarist Jonny Greenwood played as a DELIBERATE attempt to sabotage the song. Greenwood disliked the song's quiet, commercial nature, so he attempted to break or ruin the track with aggressive distortion during the verses.

But, of course, listeners LOVE those guitar stabs and they are a huge part of what people love about the song and they actually helped, in a big way, to MAKE the song a success. Personally, I can't imagine the song without them, or without the driving, amplified distortion of the chorus.

Humans rule, even when we don't mean to, lol.

Noido Dev's avatar
User was temporarily suspended for this comment. Show
4 more comments...

Ready for more?